Now on Google PlayiPhone coming soon
Learn · start here · 8 min

What can you ask an astrologer? (And what you can't.)

Astrology speaks best to questions with a time or a texture in them, such as when to change jobs. It cannot answer questions that ask for certainty.

A scholar's desk by a starlit window, with an oil lamp and palm-leaf manuscripts
In one question

What questions can astrology answer?

Good questions have a time or a texture in them. 'Is this a good year to change jobs?' 'Why do I keep clashing with my sister?' 'When does this heavy stretch ease?' The chart has something specific to say to each, because each has a house, a planet and a period behind it.

A question about when a hard stretch eases points at a period. A question about why you clash with your sister points at a house and the planets in it.

Questions astrology should not answer are the ones that ask for certainty: will I get the job, will he come back, when will I die. Horoskope's guru is instructed never to predict death, disease, accidents, legal outcomes or divorce. It is told to give you the timing and the tendency instead, which is the part you can actually use.

Here is the shape of a real answer. Example, written for this page and not a real reading: 'You are in a Saturn period, with the Moon passing your twelfth house this week. It is a tiring stretch, better for finishing than starting. The window opens in a few days, when the Moon reaches your second house.' Every clause points at a fact in your chart.

Ask your first question inside the product: it is free to start, and the guru already knows your chart from the details you give below. Ask the guru with Pro; you can try Pro free whenever you choose: 7 days, no card, and nothing is charged. The guru reads from the chart you save, so you never retype your birth details, and its answers are written to cite the chart factors behind them.

The page that does this for you: Your free daily brief.

Going deeper

How to ask an astrologer a good question

A good question has three parts. It is about you, it names an area of life, and it has a time frame. 'How does the next year look for my work?' gives an astrologer a house to read, a planet to follow and a period to date. 'What will happen to me?' gives them nothing to hold.

Questions that begin with 'how' or 'when' tend to work better than questions that begin with 'will'. 'How can I make the most of this year at work?' invites a reading. 'Will I be promoted?' invites a guess.

Ask one question at a time. A question about your work and your relationship together has two houses behind it, and each deserves its own answer.

Add the context you would give a friend. Say what you are deciding and by when, what you have already tried, and what you hope the answer will help with. Context does not change the chart, but it tells the astrologer which part of it to read first.

Say how sure you are of your birth time. A time from a birth record supports answers about houses and shorter windows. A remembered or rounded time supports answers about signs and longer stretches, and an honest astrologer will adjust.

Vague questions, and better ones

Most vague questions can be rewritten in a sentence. The better version keeps the worry and adds a subject, an area of life and a time.

Notice that each better question still leaves the decision with you. It asks for timing and texture, which is what a chart can give.

  • Vague: 'What does my future hold?' Better: 'What kind of year is the next twelve months for my work?'
  • Vague: 'Will I ever get married?' Better: 'How do I tend to be in partnership, and does the tradition read my current period as active for relationships?'
  • Vague: 'Is my partner right for me?' Better: 'We keep arguing about money. What in my chart describes how I handle money and disagreement?'
  • Vague: 'Should I quit my job?' Better: 'I am weighing a move in the next six months. Which stretch does my chart treat as better for starting something new?'
  • Vague: 'Why is everything going wrong?' Better: 'This year has felt heavy since spring. Which period or transit describes that, and what is this stretch better used for?'

Which questions does astrology handle well?

Astrology is strongest where a question meets a period. 'Which months this year suit starting a course?' has a dasha and a transit behind it, and the answer can name a season. Questions about your own patterns work well too: what tends to drain you at work, or what a close relationship tends to ask of you.

It handles self-knowledge well: your temperament, what restores you, where effort tends to pay. It is also good at planning around rhythm, such as which weeks suit finishing and which suit starting.

A useful test before you ask: could the answer change what you do this month or this year? If so, the chart probably has something to say. If the only answer you will accept is yes or no, rewrite the question first.

Which questions does astrology handle badly?

It handles badly anything that needs another person's private mind. Your chart can describe how you tend to be in partnership. It cannot read what someone else is thinking. Their side lives in their own chart, which should be read only with their agreement.

It also handles badly questions that belong to a professional. Whether to take a medicine, sign a contract or buy an investment is a question for a doctor, a lawyer or a financial adviser. A chart can describe the season you are deciding in, but it cannot weigh the facts of the decision.

And it cannot settle a single outcome on a single day. A period runs for months or years, so it describes the weather of a stretch, not the result of one event.

Be careful with questions asked from fear, too. If an answer to a frightened question comes with a warning and something to buy, it is not a reading of your chart.

How an answer is grounded in your chart

A grounded answer starts by turning your question into chart terms. Each area of life has a house: the 10th for career, the 7th for partnership, the 4th for home, the 2nd and 11th for money and gains. The astrologer reads that house, the planets in it and the planet that rules it, and the guide to the houses covers all twelve.

Then comes timing. The running dasha says whether that house's ruler is in charge of the current chapter, and if it is not, when it next is. The slow planets, Jupiter and Saturn, show which year or two puts the area in focus, and the Moon's passage narrows it further.

Take 'Is this a good year to ask for more responsibility at work?' The astrologer looks at the 10th house and its ruler, checks whether the running period belongs to a planet tied to that house, and sees where Jupiter and Saturn stand from the Moon. The answer can then say which months the tradition favours, and why.

You can check this yourself. A good answer names its sources: the house, the planet and the period. If an answer cannot say which part of your chart it came from, ask. If it still cannot, treat it as opinion.

What to do with an answer

Follow-up questions are where much of the value lies. If an answer names a window, ask what the window is better used for. If it names a planet, ask which house that planet rules in your chart and why it matters here.

Write the answer down with the date, and note any window it gave. When the window has passed, look back. You will learn how the reading lines up with your life, and you will ask sharper questions next time.

Then make the decision as you would have anyway, with the people and facts that bear on it. The chart gives you timing and a way to describe a season. What you do in that season stays yours.

Honest limits

What this cannot tell you

  • No reading can tell you what will happen. It can describe the tendency of a period and the timing the tradition gives it.
  • Ask is instructed to cite the chart factors behind its answers, but that is an instruction, not a guarantee on every answer.
  • Astrology here is for reflection and cultural interest. It describes tendencies, does not predict events, and is not medical, legal or financial advice.
Also asked

Related questions

What questions should I not ask an astrologer?

Questions that ask for certainty, such as whether you will get a job or when someone will die. A chart describes tendencies, not outcomes.

Can astrology tell me when to make a decision?

It can name the periods the tradition treats as supportive for that kind of step. The decision, and what follows it, stay yours.

Can I ask an astrologer about another person, such as my partner?

You can ask about your side: how you tend to be in partnership, and what kind of period you are in. What the other person thinks or plans is not in your chart. Reading theirs needs their birth details and, out of respect, their agreement.

How specific should my question be?

Specific enough to name an area of life and a time frame, such as your work over the next year. A yes or no is too narrow, because a chart describes periods and tendencies, not outcomes.

Do I need an exact birth time to ask a question?

No, but it changes what can be answered. Without a time, an astrologer can read your Sun, usually your Moon, and your periods as estimates. The houses and the rising sign need a time, so questions about one area of life are answered more loosely.
Your turn

See it in your own chart

See it in your chart. Free, no account. Open the page below for your own birth, or cast your free chart right here.

Your free daily brief

Free · no account

Your birth details

When and where were you born?

Your day will be dated for where you are, and the morning email lands at 8 AM there.

We do not keep the birth details you type here: the written reading is kept for up to 14 days under a one-way hash of them, so the same birth is not written twice. If you ask for the morning email, we keep the birth details it needs. Your reading opens on its own page.

Get a first look every morning by email, from the reading